If you are a writer then you know the value of a good critique partner. An effective CP has attentive eyes, ears, and emotions. He/she has x-ray vision, spotting the outer structure of scenes and chapters. Even the crumbs you scatter as you knit the overall plot throughout the story glows visible to them.
Amazing how they can see the flaws through your forest of phrases, where all you saw was your story coming together.
Over the last few weeks, my critique partners have been reading my current middle grade manuscript. A few days ago, I began studying their notes and comments, jotting down my observations of their findings. As I was doing so, I had a thought: Why not share this journey with the Alleywalkers? I mean, I did tell them I'd start sharing more from my Sheriism box.
This is the first post in my series, Studying A Critique Partner's Notes. I'll dissect how I shift through their comments to find what works for me and the intended meaning of my story, overcome the fear of axing some of their valuable advice, and show how I apply it all to my final draft.
Here goes:
Baby Steps:
- After typing 'THE END', I let the manuscript sit until after I received notes from a few CPs.
- I opened the document from CP #1 and read each comment/observation, taking my own handwritten notes as I went along until I reached the end. (In this case, I sent my CPs the manuscript in four separate docs, so I'm going through the first doc.)
- I then did the same with my other CPs' documents.
Doing this gave me a road map, an outline of what may or may not need fixing, especially when more than one CP made the same suggestion.
I waited until I received at least two CPs' suggestions back before I began this process. Each was fresh in my mind, which made it much easier for me to compare any similarities between the two. Within a day, I received a third CP's suggestions, so I included hers as well.
With this manuscript, I had four people reading for me. I hadn't received #4's suggestions yet, so I decided to use this last CP's notes as a check at the end of my revisions.
NEXT week: In The Trenches - of taking those notes.
Do you have a system to initially read your CP's edits?